Fiduciary Duty CASES

In English law, a fiduciary duty is a duty of loyalty and good faith owed by someone in a position of trust to another party. It requires the fiduciary to act solely in the beneficiary’s interests, avoiding conflicts and unauthorised gains.

Definition and Principles

Fiduciary duties arise in relationships of trust and confidence, such as trustee and beneficiary, company director and company, or solicitor and client. Equity imposes strict obligations to prevent abuse of power and protect vulnerable parties.

Requirements for Establishing

  • Relationship of trust: The fiduciary undertakes to act for or on behalf of another.
  • Duty of loyalty: The fiduciary must not place personal interests above the beneficiary’s.
  • No profit rule: Any unauthorised profit made in the course of the relationship belongs to the beneficiary.
  • No conflict rule: Fiduciaries must avoid conflicts between duty and personal interest.

Practical Applications

Classic cases include Bristol and West Building Society v Mothew (1998), defining fiduciary obligations, and Boardman v Phipps (1967), where a fiduciary had to account for profits gained despite acting in good faith.

Importance

Fiduciary duties safeguard integrity in relationships of trust, ensuring that those with power act in the best interests of others. They remain central to equity, company law, and professional regulation.

Lady justice with law books

Franbar Holdings Ltd v Patel [2008] EWHC 1534 (Ch)

Franbar Holdings Ltd, a 25% shareholder in Medicentres, sought permission to continue a derivative claim against directors Patel and du Plessis for alleged breaches of duty including diversion of business opportunities. The court refused permission, finding Franbar had adequate alternative remedies through its existing unfair prejudice petition and shareholders' action....

Lady justice next to law books

Fort Gilkicker Ltd, Re [2013] EWHC 348 (Ch)

UPMS, a member of an LLP which wholly owned Fort Gilkicker Ltd, sought permission to bring a double derivative action against a director who allegedly misappropriated a business opportunity. The court held that multiple derivative actions survived the Companies Act 2006 and granted permission to continue the claim. Facts Universal...

Law books on a desk

CMS Dolphin Ltd v Simonet [2002] BCC 600

Mr Simonet, managing director of CMS Dolphin Ltd, resigned and diverted clients Argos, Reebok and DFB to his new venture with Mr Patterson. The court held he breached fiduciary duties by appropriating maturing business opportunities and was accountable for profits, even though profits were made through a corporate vehicle. Facts...

Law books in a law library

Hopcraft v Close Brothers Ltd; Johnson v FirstRand Bank Ltd; Wrench v FirstRand Bank Ltd [2025] UKSC 33 (01 August 2025)

Three customers claimed that commissions paid by finance lenders to motor dealers for arranging hire purchase agreements constituted bribes or breaches of fiduciary duty. The Supreme Court held that dealers in typical tripartite car finance transactions do not owe fiduciary duties to customers, dismissing the bribery and equity claims, but...

Law books in a law library

Cooper v Phibbs [1867] UKHL 1 (31 May 1867)

The appellant agreed to lease a salmon fishery from respondents, believing they owned it. In fact, the fishery belonged to the appellant himself under earlier settlements. The House of Lords held the agreement should be set aside for common mistake, but subject to the appellant compensating the respondents for improvements...