Professional Negligence CASES

In English law, professional negligence occurs when a professional fails to perform their duties to the required standard, causing loss or harm to their client or another party.

Definition and Principles

Professional negligence arises from breaches of the duty of care owed by professionals—such as solicitors, accountants, architects, or doctors—who must perform services with reasonable skill and competence.

Essential Elements

  • Duty of Care: Professional owes a duty to act competently and carefully.
  • Breach: Falling below the expected professional standards.
  • Causation: Breach directly causes loss or harm.
  • Damage: Financial loss or other harm suffered by the claimant.

Common Examples

  • Incorrect legal advice causing financial loss.
  • Architectural errors resulting in structural issues.
  • Mismanagement of accounts by financial advisors.

Practical Importance

Understanding professional negligence emphasises accountability and competence among professionals, ensuring standards that protect clients and public confidence.

Lady justice with law books

Johnson v Gore Wood & Co (No 1) [2002] 2 AC 1

Mr Johnson, who conducted business through his company Westway Homes Limited, sued solicitors Gore Wood & Co. for professional negligence, claiming personal losses arising from their negligent handling of a property option. The House of Lords held his personal action was not an abuse of process despite the company having...

Law books on a desk

AB v CD Ltd [2013] EWHC 1376

Claimants sought a declaration that their professional negligence claim against an architect was settled by agreement reached through mediation. The court held that a binding settlement was concluded when the claimants accepted the defendant's offer via the mediator, despite the defendant's argument that negotiations were 'subject to contract' and required...

Law books on a desk

Rondel v Worsley [1967] UKHL 5

A convicted criminal sued his barrister for negligence in conducting his defence at trial. The House of Lords unanimously held that barristers enjoy immunity from negligence claims arising from their conduct of litigation, based on public policy considerations including the barrister's duty to the court and the administration of justice....

Law books on a desk

Whitehead v Searle [2008] EWCA Civ 1093

A mother issued a wrongful birth claim after her son was born with spina bifida. Following her suicide and subsequent negligent delay by her solicitors, her estate and the child’s father sued the solicitors and barrister. The Court of Appeal granted limited permission to appeal only on the father’s personal...

Lady justice next to law books

Phelps v Hillingdon LBC [2000] UKHL 47

Several linked appeals considered whether local education authorities and their staff could be liable in negligence for failures in identifying and addressing children’s special educational needs. The House of Lords recognised duties of care, allowed most appeals, and treated educational under-provision as actionable damage, including economic loss. Facts Phelps Pamela...

Law books in a law library

Jones v Kaney [2011] UKSC 13 (29 March 2011)

A claimant in a personal injury case sued his expert witness psychologist for negligently signing a joint statement that damaged his case and led to a reduced settlement. The Supreme Court abolished the immunity from negligence claims that expert witnesses had previously enjoyed when providing evidence for their instructing clients....

Law books in a law library

Arthur J.S Hall and Co. v. Simons and Barratt v. Ansell and Others v. Scholfield Roberts and Hill [2000] UKHL 38 (20 July 2000)

Three clients sued their solicitors for negligence in civil litigation matters. The House of Lords was asked whether advocates' immunity from negligence claims should continue. The House unanimously abolished the immunity for civil proceedings, fundamentally changing the law to allow clients to sue negligent advocates. Facts Three separate appeals were...

Lady justice with law books

Hayes v Dodd [1988] EWCA Civ 8 (07 July 1988)

A couple purchased a motor repair business relying on their solicitors' negligent advice that a right of way existed. When the access was blocked, their business failed. The court assessed damages on a 'no-transaction' basis, awarding expenditure less recoveries, but disallowed damages for mental distress in commercial contracts. Facts Mr...