Consideration CASES

In English contract law, consideration refers to something of value exchanged between parties, which is essential for forming a legally enforceable contract.

Definition and Principles

Consideration involves a benefit or detriment exchanged between contracting parties. It can include payment, services, goods, promises, or abstaining from actions a party is legally entitled to perform. For a contract to be valid, consideration must move from the promisee.

Key Characteristics

  • Sufficient but not adequate: Consideration must have some tangible value in law but does not need to match the economic worth of the exchanged promise.
  • Past consideration: Actions performed before the promise was made generally cannot serve as valid consideration.
  • Existing legal duty: Performing an existing legal duty typically does not constitute valid consideration unless additional benefits or duties arise.

Types of Consideration

  • Executed consideration: An act already performed when the agreement is made.
  • Executory consideration: A promise to perform acts or obligations in the future.

Practical Importance

Consideration ensures mutual exchange and fairness within contractual agreements, distinguishing enforceable promises from mere gratuitous statements or gifts.

Lady justice with law books

Mountford v Scott [1974] EWCA Civ 10 (17 October 1974)

The defendant granted the plaintiffs an option to purchase his house for £10,000, receiving £1 consideration. He later attempted to withdraw but the plaintiffs exercised the option. The Court of Appeal upheld specific performance, confirming that nominal consideration supports a valid irrevocable option, and the resulting contract was enforceable. Facts...

Lady justice with law books

Foakes v Beer [1884] UKHL 1 (16 May 1884)

Dr Foakes owed Mrs Beer £2090 19s under a judgment. They agreed he would pay in instalments without Mrs Beer taking proceedings. After full payment of principal, Mrs Beer claimed interest. The House of Lords held that payment of a lesser sum cannot satisfy a greater debt without fresh consideration....

Law books on a desk

Eurymedon, the [1974] UKPC 1

Stevedores negligently damaged cargo while unloading. A bill of lading, to which they were not a party, contained an exemption clause extending protection to them. The Privy Council held the stevedores could rely on the clause, creating a binding contract through their performance. Facts A valuable drilling machine was shipped...