Fiduciary Duty CASES

Lady justice next to law books

QBE Management Services (UK) Ltd v Dymoke [2012] EWHC 80 (QB)

Senior employees of QBE’s British Marine unit covertly planned a rival P&I business with PRO, soliciting colleagues, misusing confidential information and courting brokers while still employed. The High Court found extensive breaches of fidelity, fiduciary and confidentiality duties, granted springboard injunctions and awarded substantial damages, although most non‑compete covenants were...

Lady justice next to law books

Hopcraft v Close Brothers Ltd; Johnson v FirstRand Bank Ltd; Wrench v FirstRand Bank Ltd [2025] UKSC 33 (01 August 2025)

Three customers claimed that commissions paid by finance lenders to motor dealers for arranging hire purchase agreements constituted bribes or breaches of fiduciary duty. The Supreme Court held that dealers in typical tripartite car finance transactions do not owe fiduciary duties to customers, dismissing the bribery and equity claims, but...

Lady justice with law books

Cooper v Phibbs [1867] UKHL 1 (31 May 1867)

The appellant agreed to lease a salmon fishery from respondents, believing they owned it. In fact, the fishery belonged to the appellant himself under earlier settlements. The House of Lords held the agreement should be set aside for common mistake, but subject to the appellant compensating the respondents for improvements...