Specific Performance CASES

In English law, specific performance is an equitable remedy compelling a party to fulfil their contractual obligations, typically used when monetary compensation (damages) would be inadequate.

Definition and Principles

Specific performance involves a court order mandating exact compliance with contract terms, particularly applied in cases involving unique or rare items, such as land or specific goods.

Conditions for Granting

  • Inadequacy of Damages: Monetary compensation must be insufficient to remedy the breach.
  • Feasibility: Performance must be clearly defined and practically enforceable.
  • Fairness: It must not cause undue hardship or injustice to the performing party.

Limitations

Courts generally avoid specific performance for personal services, ongoing supervision requirements, or vague and uncertain obligations.

Practical Importance

Understanding specific performance helps parties recognise potential consequences of breach, encouraging contract compliance, especially where unique assets are involved.

Law books on a desk

Mountford v Scott [1974] EWCA Civ 10 (17 October 1974)

The defendant granted the plaintiffs an option to purchase his house for £10,000, receiving £1 consideration. He later attempted to withdraw but the plaintiffs exercised the option. The Court of Appeal upheld specific performance, confirming that nominal consideration supports a valid irrevocable option, and the resulting contract was enforceable. Facts...

Law books in a law library

Lumley v Wagner [1852] EWHC Ch J96 (26 May 1852)

Opera singer Johanna Wagner contracted to perform exclusively at Her Majesty's Theatre for three months but then agreed to sing at a rival theatre. The Court granted an injunction preventing her from singing elsewhere, establishing that equity can enforce negative contractual stipulations even where specific performance of positive obligations is...