March 19, 2026
Mr Spencer suffered a minor knee injury at work which led to leg amputation. Later, while filling his car at a petrol station without using his prosthesis or walking sticks, he fell and sustained further serious injuries. The Court held the original tortfeasor remained liable for the subsequent injury, reduced...
March 19, 2026
The Heimgar suffered collision damage from the Carslogie, then heavy weather damage on voyage to repairs. Both were repaired concurrently. The House of Lords held the Carslogie's owners were not liable for detention damages as the Heimgar was already immobilised by the weather damage when collision repairs occurred. Facts On...
March 19, 2026
The claimant suffered an ankle fracture due to the defendant council's negligence. The defendant sought to amend its defence to argue that negligent NHS surgery broke the chain of causation. The District Judge refused permission, but the High Court allowed the appeal, holding there is no rule requiring 'grossly negligent'...
March 19, 2026
Mrs Webb, a polio survivor, injured her knee tripping at work. Her consultant negligently advised amputation without proper investigation or discussing alternatives. The Court of Appeal held that had she been properly advised, she would not have consented to amputation, and apportioned liability between her employer and the NHS Trust....
March 19, 2026
Following a major oil spill off Nigeria's coast in December 2011, claimants argued there was a continuing nuisance while oil remained on their land, allowing fresh limitation periods. The Supreme Court held that a one-off event causing ongoing damage does not constitute a continuing nuisance; the cause of action accrued...
March 19, 2026
A woman was raped by an elder of the Jehovah's Witnesses. The Supreme Court considered whether the organisation was vicariously liable. While the relationship between elder and organisation was akin to employment (stage 1 satisfied), the rape was not sufficiently connected to his authorised activities as elder (stage 2 failed)....
March 19, 2026
A horse trainer bought oats matching a sample shown to him, but mistakenly believed they were old oats when they were new (green) oats. The court held that the seller was not obliged to correct the buyer's unilateral mistake. This case established the objective test for contract formation. Facts Mr...
March 19, 2026
RTS agreed to supply automated equipment to Müller under a Letter of Intent while negotiating detailed contract terms. Work proceeded without a formal contract being signed. The Supreme Court held that by their conduct, particularly a variation agreement on 25 August 2005, the parties waived the ‘subject to contract’ requirement...
March 19, 2026
Reveille produced MasterChef US and negotiated with Anotech to integrate cookware products into episodes and license the MasterChef brand. A Deal Memo stated it was not binding until signed by Reveille, but Reveille never signed. The Court held a binding contract was formed through Reveille's conduct in performing the agreement's...
March 19, 2026
Mr Partridge advertised wild birds for sale in a magazine. He was charged with offering for sale a bramblefinch contrary to the Protection of Birds Act 1954. The court held the advertisement was merely an invitation to treat, not an offer for sale, establishing that advertisements are generally invitations to...
March 19, 2026
An auctioneer advertised office furniture for sale at auction. The plaintiff travelled to attend but the goods were withdrawn. The court held that an advertisement of an auction is merely a declaration of intent, not an offer, so the auctioneer was not liable for the plaintiff's wasted expenses. Facts The...
March 19, 2026
Wang Global sought permission to appeal against a costs order made against it as a non-party under section 51 of the Supreme Court Act 1981. The Court of Appeal granted permission, finding it arguable that the judge below had not properly applied legal principles when exercising his discretion on non-party...
March 19, 2026
McLean offered to sell iron warrants to Stevenson, open till Monday. Stevenson sent an inquiry about modified terms, which McLean ignored before selling to another party. The court held Stevenson's inquiry was not a counter-offer rejecting the original offer, and their subsequent acceptance created a binding contract. Facts The plaintiff,...
March 19, 2026
Dodds offered to sell property to Dickinson, promising to keep the offer open until Friday 9 AM, but sold to a third party (Allan) before Dickinson accepted. Dickinson, having learned of the sale to Allan from an intermediary, nevertheless attempted to accept and sued for specific performance. The Court of...
March 19, 2026
Van Tienhoven posted an offer to sell tinplates from Cardiff to Byrne in New York. Byrne accepted by telegram upon receipt, but Van Tienhoven had already posted a revocation letter. The court held that revocation is only effective upon actual communication to the offeree, not upon posting. Facts Van Tienhoven...
March 19, 2026
Claimants alleged their solicitors were negligent in failing to advise that a share sale transaction had completed, thereby losing their right to enforce undertakings for payment. The court found completion did not occur as no confirmatory telephone call took place between solicitors, and dismissed the negligence claim. Facts The claimants,...
March 19, 2026
Mr Grant applied for shares in an insurance company. The company posted a letter of allotment which was lost in the post and never received. The Court of Appeal held that a valid contract existed because acceptance is effective upon posting, even if the letter never arrives. This case affirmed...
March 19, 2026
A dispute arose over a rare Ferrari 250 GTO gearbox separated from the car sold for $44 million. The buyer sought specific performance to obtain the gearbox. The Court of Appeal held that the buyer was entitled to the gearbox but must pay the seller $500,000 plus shipping costs, affirming...
March 19, 2026
Brinkibon, a London company, sent acceptance of a contract by telex to Stahag in Vienna. The House of Lords held that for instantaneous communications like telex, a contract is formed where acceptance is received, thus the contract was formed in Austria, not England. Facts Brinkibon Ltd, a company based in...
March 17, 2026
At first glance, THG Plc v Zedra Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd looks like a technical limitations appeal. In reality, it is a major statement about the nature of the unfair prejudice jurisdiction itself. By a 4 – 1 majority, the Supreme Court held on 25 February 2026 that a petition...
March 16, 2026
HMRC argued that part-time football referees in the National Group were employees of PGMOL for tax and National Insurance purposes. The Supreme Court held that individual match contracts satisfied the requirements of mutuality of obligation and control necessary for employment, remitting the case to determine overall employment status. Facts Professional...
March 16, 2026
Tesco sought to remove 'retained pay' from employees who had relocated in 2007 by dismissing and rehiring them without this benefit. The Supreme Court held that an implied term prevented Tesco from exercising its termination power to defeat the promised permanent retained pay, and granted an injunction restraining such dismissals....
March 16, 2026
Spain and Zimbabwe appealed against registration of ICSID arbitration awards in the UK, claiming state immunity. The Supreme Court held that by ratifying the ICSID Convention, particularly Article 54(1), contracting states waived their immunity from adjudicative jurisdiction for recognition and enforcement proceedings, while preserving immunity from execution only. Facts Two...
March 16, 2026
A daughter claimed financial provision from her deceased father's estate under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. The Supreme Court held that a success fee payable under a conditional fee agreement cannot be included in an award for reasonable financial provision, as this would circumvent section 58A(6)...
March 16, 2026
Data centre developers claimed enterprise zone capital allowances for construction expenditure incurred in the second 10-year period under a 'golden contract' made within the first period. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, holding that section 298 requires contractual commitment to the specific expenditure by the tenth anniversary, not merely that...
April 30, 2026
National Case Law Archive
April 30, 2026
National Case Law Archive
April 30, 2026
National Case Law Archive