Conditions and Warranties CASES

In English law, conditions and warranties are types of contractual terms defining obligations, breaches of which lead to different legal consequences.

Conditions

A condition is a fundamental term at the heart of a contract. Breaching a condition allows the injured party to terminate the contract and claim damages.

Example:

  • Timely delivery of goods considered essential by parties.

Warranties

A warranty is a lesser term, collateral to the main purpose of a contract. Breach of warranty entitles the injured party only to claim damages, not terminate the contract.

Example:

  • Minor defects in delivered goods that don’t affect overall contract purpose.

Key Differences

  • Breach of condition: termination and damages.
  • Breach of warranty: damages only, contract continues.

Practical Importance

Clearly distinguishing between conditions and warranties ensures parties understand potential consequences of breaches, helping manage risks and contractual expectations.

Maredelanto Compania Naviera SA v Bergbau-Handel GmbH (The Mihalis Angelos) [1970] EWCA Civ 4 (01 July 1970)

Shipowners chartered a vessel stating she was 'expected ready to load about 1st July 1965' without reasonable grounds for that expectation. Charterers purported to cancel for force majeure when cargo was unavailable. The Court held the 'expected ready to load' clause was a condition, breach of which entitled charterers to cancel, and that only nominal damages were recoverable where the charterers would inevitably have cancelled anyway.

Ronaasen & Son v Arcos Ltd [1933] UKHL 1

The buyers rejected timber staves that were commercially usable but did not strictly match the contractual thickness. The House of Lords held that goods sold by description must comply precisely with that description, so the buyers were entitled to reject the shipment.