Unconscionable bargain CASES

In English law, an unconscionable bargain refers to a transaction so fundamentally unfair or oppressive due to one party’s exploitation of the other’s vulnerability that it may be set aside by the courts.

Definition and Principles

An unconscionable bargain arises when one party, taking advantage of a significantly stronger position or the other party’s weakness, enters into a contract that grossly favours them.

Elements of Unconscionability

  • Unequal Bargaining Power: Clear disparity in parties’ power or position.
  • Exploitation: Advantage taken of the weaker party’s vulnerability or distress.
  • Grossly Unfair Terms: Contractual terms significantly disadvantage one party.

Remedies

Courts may intervene to rescind or adjust unconscionable contracts to restore fairness and protect vulnerable parties.

Practical Importance

Recognising unconscionable bargains protects vulnerable individuals from exploitation, promoting fairness and equity in contractual relationships.

Law books on a desk

Mountford v Scott [1974] EWCA Civ 10 (17 October 1974)

The defendant granted the plaintiffs an option to purchase his house for £10,000, receiving £1 consideration. He later attempted to withdraw but the plaintiffs exercised the option. The Court of Appeal upheld specific performance, confirming that nominal consideration supports a valid irrevocable option, and the resulting contract was enforceable. Facts...